Dock Line
The concrete Hubert H. Humphrey Building, headquarters of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, seen from across Independence Avenue with flags at the entrance
The Hubert H. Humphrey Building, HHS headquarters in Washington, photographed April 7, 2014, by Gunnar Klack. Cropped from a 2,500-by-1,352-pixel original and scaled down to 1,600 by 900, with no upscaling. This is not a photograph of a Head Start classroom or of the secretary signing the rule. Photo: Gunnar Klack / Wikimedia Commons; CC BY-SA 4.0. Source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Hubert-H-Humphrey-Building-Marcel-Breuer-and-Herbert-Beckhard-Independence-Avenue-Washington-DC-Apr-2014.jpg (Gunnar Klack / Wikimedia Commons; CC BY-SA 4.0. Source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Hubert-H-Humphrey-Building-Marcel-Breuer-and-Herbert-Beckhard-Independence-Avenue-Washington-DC-Apr-2014.jpg)

Erastus Smith

November 22, 2026 · 4 min read

HHS Issues Final Rule Removing Head Start Wage and Benefit Mandates

A final rule published Nov. 16, signed by HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., rescinds 2024 Head Start wage and benefit requirements, effective Jan. 15, 2027.

The facts come first below. My opinion follows in the section marked as opinion.

The Department of Health and Human Services published a final rule in the Federal Register on Monday, Nov. 16, that removes federal wage and benefit mandates imposed on Head Start programs in 2024. The rule, titled "Restoring Flexibility To Support Head Start Program Access," is signed by HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. According to the official text posted by the Government Publishing Office, the effective date is Jan. 15, 2027. The rule has not yet taken effect.

The Administration for Children and Families, through the Office of Head Start, said in the official text that the rule removes requirements "related to wages and benefits that the Administration believes are not in line with the plain language of the Head Start Act and are costly and overly prescriptive for Head Start programs and staff." ACF "estimates these changes will result in over $2 billion in future cost savings for Head Start programs." Those figures are the agency's estimates. The rescissions, the summary says, target the costliest parts of the 2024 final rule, "Supporting the Head Start Workforce and Consistent Quality Programming."

The official text states that the new rule "removes the wage and benefit requirements in Sec. 1302.90(e) and (f) that were introduced in the 2024 final rule, restoring greater flexibility to local Head Start programs." It eliminates requirements that would have required programs to develop or update a pay scale for all staff; provide education staff with wages comparable to public preschool teachers; provide all staff a salary sufficient to cover basic costs of living; and promote wage comparability across Head Start Preschool and Early Head Start. It also eliminates requirements to provide staff with specified benefits.

In the 2024 rule, ACF "estimated that by the time the wage and benefit requirements were fully implemented in 2031, funded enrollment could decline by more than 100,000 slots." The new rule says the current administration "does not believe that a one size fits all approach to staff compensation is the appropriate way to address these challenges, particularly when doing so may reduce access to Head Start services." ACF said it is rescinding the 2024 requirements "well in advance of the 2031 compliance deadline" so programs do not keep making operational and financial changes for rules that will no longer apply.

Responding to comments, ACF wrote that, "absent additional appropriations, approximately 106,000 funded Head Start slots would need to be eliminated for programs to meet the requirements by the applicable compliance deadline." Those figures are the agency's estimates, not a count of slots already cut. The rule also says it "does not prohibit the maintenance of current compensation structures, nor does it encourage grant recipients to reduce compensation for program staff." In a later analysis, ACF combined the 2024 rule's estimated 2031 wage and benefit costs and described "a transfer of approximately $2.1 billion in future expenditures."

The Federal Head Start program, the rule says, provides early education and other comprehensive services to low-income pregnant women and children from the prenatal period to age 5, and dates to 1965. ACF said it received nearly 300 public comments on the proposed changes. Some commenters supported the flexibility and called the 2024 requirements an unfunded mandate. Others, including "two multi-signatory congressional letters," opposed removing the wage and benefit requirements and raised concerns about workforce stability, compensation, and equity with public schools.

Kennedy signed the amendments to 45 CFR Part 1302 as secretary of Health and Human Services. The rule is a separate action from earlier HHS personnel news reported in Dock Line, including White House Withdraws Heidi Overton's Nomination to Lead the FDA.

Opinion:

Head Start exists to serve poor children and their mothers, not to give Washington a nationwide pay scale. If the price of a federal wage mandate is the loss of more than 100,000 slots, the children who would have occupied those slots pay first. ACF's own 2024 estimate said that tradeoff was coming. The new rule is a decision not to force it.

None of that means Head Start teachers should be poorly paid. Programs should pay what they can to keep good staff, and many already try to do so. What they should not be required to do is shrink enrollment, or lay people off, in order to obey a one-size-fits-all compensation formula that Congress did not fund. Local directors, who see their own labor markets and their own waiting lists, are in a better position to make that choice than a rule written in Washington.

The effective date is still weeks away, and the estimates in the Federal Register are estimates. They should be read that way. But the principle is sound. A program created to interrupt poverty should not be told to serve fewer children in the name of a mandate the Treasury will not pay for.