Dock Line
Official Senate portrait of Sen. Shelley Moore Capito of West Virginia, smiling in a bright pink jacket and a pearl necklace
Official U.S. Senate portrait of Sen. Shelley Moore Capito, R-W.Va., dated Feb. 10, 2015, from the United States Congress. Cropped from a 3,280-by-4,155-pixel original and scaled down to 1,600 by 900, with no upscaling. Capito was a lead sponsor of the permitting bill the Senate passed Thursday. This portrait is not from Thursday night's vote. Photo: United States Congress / U.S. Senate; public domain (U.S. government work). Source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Shelley_Moore_Capito_official_Senate_photo.jpg (United States Congress / U.S. Senate; public domain (U.S. government work). Source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Shelley_Moore_Capito_official_Senate_photo.jpg)

Erastus Smith

November 20, 2026 · 5 min read

Senate Passes Energy Permitting Overhaul Bill, 62-33

The Senate on Thursday night passed H.R. 2347, as amended, the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, 62-33. The bill now goes to the House.

The facts come first below. My opinion follows in the section marked as opinion.

The Senate on Thursday night passed a long-sought overhaul of federal energy permitting. According to the Senate Daily Press, the chamber passed H.R. 2347, the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026, as amended, at 10:02 p.m. Eastern by a vote of 62 to 33. The official Senate roll call, vote 270 of the 119th Congress, second session, records the result as "Bill Passed," with 62 yeas, 33 nays, and 5 not voting, on passage of H.R. 2347, as amended. The official roll-call page lists the measure under the original title of H.R. 2347, a bill to amend the Internal Revenue Code; the short title used here comes from the Daily Press, which said the roll call on passage began at 9:30 p.m. Eastern. The official page lists a vote date of Nov. 19, 2026, 09:30 AM, but its modify time is 10:28 p.m., which matches the Daily Press evening times.

The official tally of the 33 nays is 30 Democrats, Independent Sen. Bernie Sanders of Vermont, and Republican Sens. Josh Hawley of Missouri and Mike Rounds of South Dakota. The Daily Press listed 15 Democrats and Independents voting in favor: Sens. Coons, Fetterman, Gallego, Heinrich, Hickenlooper, King, Klobuchar, Peters, Reed, Rosen, Schatz, Schumer, Slotkin, Warner, and Whitehouse. It said Hawley and Rounds voted against the bill. Sens. Cassidy, Cornyn, McConnell, Murphy, and Tuberville did not vote, the Daily Press and the official roll call both show. The official record lists 14 Democrats and Independent Sen. Angus King of Maine among the yeas, matching that Daily Press list of 15.

Roll Call reported that the measure is a substitute built from a bipartisan permitting bill unveiled before the midterm elections, and that the chamber did not consider any additional amendments on Thursday. The sponsors named in that account are Environment and Public Works Chair Shelley Moore Capito, R-W.Va., the panel's ranking member, Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse, D-R.I., Energy and Natural Resources Chair Mike Lee, R-Utah, and that panel's ranking member, Sen. Martin Heinrich, D-N.M. Capito said before passage, "This bill has threaded a needle the likes of which this chamber has not seen in a while, and we've got to take advantage of this opportunity."

According to Roll Call, the bill would overhaul the federal permitting system for electric power lines, wind and solar farms, hard rock mining, oil drilling, and more. The newspaper said it includes changes to how reviews are conducted and permits are issued under the National Environmental Policy Act, the National Historic Preservation Act, the Endangered Species Act, the Federal Power Act, and the Clean Water Act. It said the bill includes provisions intended to ensure electricity ratepayers are not saddled with the costs of bringing power to data centers, and would give the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission new authority over interstate transmission lines. It also said the bill would provide legal recourse when administrations discriminate against certain forms of energy or seek to revisit permits on ideological grounds, a provision Roll Call said was intended in part to address the Trump administration's actions to delay or block solar and wind energy projects.

Roll Call said Sens. Jeff Merkley and Ron Wyden, both Democrats of Oregon, would not consent to a time agreement for a limited set of amendments, and that Merkley then objected to a unanimous consent request to consider amendments on the floor. As a result, an additional manager's package of changes to the already-adopted substitute "fell by the wayside," the newspaper said, including language that would have addressed eminent-domain concerns raised by Hawley and Rounds and a refinement meant to keep artificial-intelligence "hyperscalers" from escaping the ratepayer provisions through a loophole. "None of those changes made it into the bill as a result of the stalemate over amendments," Roll Call reported. After passage, the Daily Press said that at 10:45 p.m. Eastern, Sen. Schatz asked consent that the Senate take up and pass the Lee-Heinrich-Capito amendment as an enrollment correction, and that Sen. Merkley objected.

The bill is not yet law. Roll Call said it now moves to the House after the Thanksgiving recess, and that Speaker Mike Johnson, R-La., said last week that the bill can pass in the House. The newspaper also said the White House expressed support for the bill in a statement of administration policy this month, and that industry groups including the American Petroleum Institute, the American Clean Power Association, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, and the National Association of Manufacturers have endorsed it, while the Sierra Club, the Natural Resources Defense Council, a coalition of 17 Democratic states, and the National Congress of American Indians have expressed opposition. Merkley said before the vote, "I'm hoping to have a full opportunity to address the many legitimate concerns that stakeholders have raised with this bill."

The fight over who pays for the power used by large computing facilities is also the subject of Dock Line's earlier report that a GAO Finds No Agency Fully Met Data Center Rules Before They Expired.

Opinion:

It should not take a generation to build a power line or a plant. Families have been paying more for electricity, and it is fair to ask whether data centers should be allowed to drop those costs onto ordinary ratepayers. Getting 62 votes for a permitting bill, including 15 Democrats and Independents, is not a small thing. Senator Capito was right that the coalition was unusual. Unusual is not the same as finished, and it is not the same as wise in every particular.

The Senate passed the bill without the extra amendments its own sponsors had been prepared to consider. That stalemate left on the table a fix that, as Roll Call described it, was meant to keep large artificial-intelligence operators from slipping out of the ratepayer protections, and it left unaddressed the eminent-domain concerns that helped drive two Republican no votes. Those are not abstract complaints. If the House simply cheers the vote count and ignores the text, it will have done the public no favors. Christians should want abundant energy, honest prices, and a process that does not steamroll neighbors or treat historic and created things as obstacles to be waived away. Passage in one chamber is a start. It is not a blessing, and it is not the last word.