
Trump Orders Contractors to Notify White House of Congress Requests
President Trump signed Executive Order 14438 on Friday, directing federal contractors to notify the White House of congressional requests and to follow privilege instructions.
The facts come first below. My opinion follows in the section marked as opinion.
President Donald Trump on Friday signed an executive order directing federal contractors and subcontractors to notify the White House of congressional requests for information and to withhold communications that the administration determines are protected by executive privilege, according to the official text and Saturday reports by CBS News, publishing an Associated Press dispatch, and Fox News.
The order, Executive Order 14438, is titled "Protecting the Executive's Privileges and Enhancing Efficiencies in Federal Contracting." A White House fact sheet dated Nov. 20 said the president signed it "to ensure Federal contractors and subcontractors protect the Executive Branch's interest and rights, and ensure economical and efficient work."
The order says the doctrine of executive privilege "protects confidential executive branch information from disclosure" and that "Protecting this information from unauthorized disclosure, including to members of the Congress, is vital to the functioning of the executive branch." It continues, "The ability of the Congress to seek executive branch information is limited; it cannot seek information from executive branch departments and agencies (agencies), employees, or Federal contractors without a valid legislative purpose that does not intrude on core Executive functions."
The text says certain congressional leaders "have threatened to intrude on these Executive prerogatives by seeking confidential executive branch information from agencies and harassing private companies that contract with the Federal Government." It states that policy is "to protect confidential information and enhance economy and efficiency in Federal contracting by preventing and prohibiting uncoordinated disclosures of information pursuant to congressional requests," according to the official order.
Under Section 2, "all Federal contractors must immediately" notify the White House and the contracting agencies "of any pending or future congressional request respecting the contractors' communications or work with the executive branch," and "abide by any instructions received from the White House and contracting agency related to the withholding of communications that the White House or the agency has determined are protected by executive privilege," the text says. Agencies are to coordinate "on appropriate responses to such congressional requests," and to require contractors to ensure that subcontractors comply as well.
If a contractor or subcontractor fails to comply, the order says agencies "shall consider whether to take all appropriate actions, consistent with applicable law, to enforce the terms of this order, including the potential termination or cancellation of contracts and the potential debarment or suspension of contractors." The Office of Management and Budget is directed to develop guidance. The order also says it shall be "implemented consistent with applicable law" and "is not intended to, and does not, create any right or benefit, substantive or procedural, enforceable at law or in equity by any party against the United States."
The Associated Press dispatch published Saturday by CBS News said the order was issued late Friday and applies to "all contractors and subcontractors, a universe of tens of thousands of businesses." It said Democrats, who take over Congress in January, have made government contracts a top investigative target, "noting that federal money has been flowing to companies linked with Mr. Trump's family, particularly at the Pentagon." That accusation is reported by the AP as the Democrats' point, not as an independent finding. Fox News said the order "could invite legal challenges, particularly if contractors are told to withhold records sought by subpoena."
Both outlets also described a related directive from White House Counsel Will Scharf. The Associated Press dispatch published by CBS News said that on Monday, Nov. 16, Scharf told agencies they must seek approval from his office and the White House Office of Legislative Affairs before agreeing to appear before Congress, and that in a letter to Rep. Robert Garcia, the top Democrat on the House Oversight Committee, he suggested some investigations may amount to "blatant criminality." Garcia sent document-preservation letters earlier this week to members of the president's family and senior officials, CBS and Fox News reported, a development Dock Line covered earlier in House Democrat Sends Record-Preservation Letters to Trump Allies.
Opinion:
Executive privilege is not a slogan. The Supreme Court has recognized it as part of the separation of powers, and the order is right to say that confidential executive information needs protection, including from "unauthorized disclosure" to members of Congress. The executive branch cannot do serious work if every confidence is treated as a press release. Congress, for its part, has a real job. Oversight is not a courtesy the White House grants when it feels like it. The order itself says Congress needs a "valid legislative purpose that does not intrude on core Executive functions." That is a limit on Congress. It is not a license for the executive to decide, alone and in every case, what a private company may hand over.
The hard point is the lever. The order tells contractors to notify the White House and to "abide by any instructions" on withholding what the administration has "determined are protected by executive privilege." If they do not, agencies are to consider canceling contracts and barring firms from future work, "consistent with applicable law," the text says. That last phrase matters. A president may protect genuine deliberations. He may not, by threatening a company's livelihood, turn every congressional request into a permission slip from the West Wing. If this is tested against a lawful subpoena, the courts should say so plainly. The order does not repeal Congress's subpoena power.
The incoming majority will investigate, and some of that will be politics. The order accuses leaders of "harassing private companies." Harassment is not oversight, and oversight is not a crime. White House counsel's suggestion, reported by the Associated Press, that some inquiries may amount to "blatant criminality" should be proved in court if it is to be more than a warning shot. Contractors should not be crushed between two branches. Privilege should be asserted carefully, and Congress should ask for what it has a right to see.


